Hi Omar,

Back in June, I sent the same PrepCast Simulator Question ID: 610083 to the Simulator HelpDesk via email: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it..

I hope the response below from Stan Po, MBA, PMP, PMI-ACP, CSM, gives you PrepCast’s thought process on this particular scenario.

-Lisa

“As clarified in the explanation, our team had an extensive debate on the subject of change requests and the sequence of steps involved in this process. The reason being is that the PMBOK® Guide does not do a good job in explaining the exact process in detail. We have discussed the sequence of steps among our team of certified project management professionals and have concluded that the first thing that should be done when a change is requested on a project is the physical creation of the change request, a document if you wish, or in other words, filling out a form. Otherwise, on what basis would a project manager, the project team, the change control board (CCB) spend time evaluating a request that is not even documented? While the PMBOK® Guide does not explicitly specify the above sequence, it does imply that a change request should first be documented and only then evaluated. On page 120, the PMBOK® Guide reads, "Change control meetings are held with a change control board (CCB) that is responsible for meeting and reviewing the change requests and approving, rejecting, or deferring change requests. Most changes will have some sort of impact on time, cost, resources, or risks. Assessing the impact of the changes is an essential part of the meeting. Alternatives to the requested changes may also be discussed and proposed. Finally, the decision is communicated to the request owner or group." Therefore, the fact the CCB meets to review change requests and evaluate their impact on project constraints implies the change requests have already been submitted prior to the meeting.

Therefore, we still strongly believe that creating a change request is the 'first' step the project manager should take in this scenario.”

Hi

Please your kind advise regarding to choose the option between 'Change Request' & 'Evaluate the impact of change on all constraints' in CR questions.

Normally, we have seen two scenarios of Change Request where in one of them one stakeholders wants to add a new requirement/scope/functionality to the project where the project manager advises him/her to submit the change request first and then they will evaluate the impact of the change. Other scenario is where one the project team member or project manager him/herself wants to apply some modification to the process or deliverable. in the later case we have seen the first option is to evaluate the impact of the change and then submit the change request.

I have attached two screenshots covering the above-mentioned scenarios, one from the Prepcast where the correct answer is 'Create Change Request' and the other from Simplilearn where the correct answer is 'Evaluate the impact of the change on constrains'.

Please advise the correct answer and also suggest whether the above two scenarios are totally different.